The question
Purchased a condo in Naples Florida in 09/24. Less than 24 hours after closing, HOA notified us that we have a balcony water leak that leaks into the garage that needs repaired. The leak was never disclosed prior to this notification. The HOA & prior owner(s) had communication about the leak. It was obviously a pre-existing leak based on the eroded epoxy paint and concrete damage on the garage floor & ceiling. Neighbors have also stated the elak has been going on for years. We had a contractor on site that made the same statements about it being on-going for years. After months of going back & forth, HOA replaced two balcony floor drains and a hand railing which were all suspected of being the leak source, the leak remains. We are now being told by the HOA that its our responsibility to make the repairs at our cost. Estimated cost exceeds $225K. Are we protected by the Johnson v Davis Law?